When illuminated, these votive holders cast an eyeful of moody shadows on the walls.
Tear a sheet of black construction paper into about a dozen small rectangles that measure roughly 1¼ inch by ½ inch. Use a hole punch to add two eyes to each piece.

Brush a portion of a plain, glass votive holder with Mod Podge, affix a paper rectangle, then paint more Mod Podge over it. Add the other pieces the same way, making sure the edges overlap.
When the candleholder is dry, use a tiny paintbrush and black paint to add little round pupils inside the eyes.