Kids will become equally bewitched by this version of the classic pin-the-tail on the donkey.
Hang the witch at kids' eye level on the wall.
Wad up rubber cement into gumball-size warts (one for each player). If necessary, use a glue stick to make them stickier right before the game.
Blindfolded, kids take turns trying to stick a wart on the witch's nose. You can use labels or stickers to keep track of whose wart is whose.